How Adults Politically Repress Young People

Online and offline, adults (including parents, teachers, administrators, law enforcement, and other government officials) use a wide variety of tactics to suppress youth political action.

Share

In my previous essay on the geography of youth, I mentioned how the adult control over youth spaces is often used to censor young people - especially those who dare to challenge the status quo.

Wherever young people spend their time - whether physically or digitally - they are surveilled, judged, mocked, and threatened by adults. Regardless of their consent, their personal data is used for the benefit of advertisers and law enforcement. Youth social media bans may claim a paternalistic concern for kids' mental well-being as the instigating factor for passing legislation, but as we can see with the TikTok ban, they are also motivated by a desire to censor young people politically and socially. The legislative restrictions for young people in digital spaces closely mirror the longstanding restrictions they've faced in physical spaces as well.

I wrote that piece over a year ago, and since then, I've come to learn a lot more about how the political repression of young people operates: online and offline, inside and outside the imperial core, now and throughout history. Turns out, young people face a lot of pressure through many different avenues to make sure their speech is acceptable to adult society. Here's what I found.

At Protests

Many view young people as a coddled population (see: David Lancy's concept of a "neontocracy" or Jean Twenge's "iGen"). But at the same time, when those same young people choose to protest corruption, austerity, or crimes against humanity, their governments don't pull any punches.

During Nepal's 2025 "Gen Z Revolution," tens of thousands of young people protested government corruption and nepotism. Law enforcement used tear gas, water cannons, batons, rubber bullets, and live ammunition against the protestors. As protestors were taken to the Civil Service Hospital in Kathmandu, police also breached the hospital, assaulting patients and deploying tear gas.

Similarly, police have continued to brutalize protestors throughout France's ongoing high school movement against poor educational conditions. Reuters has documented 28 cases of injuries caused by the police, involving the "use of rubber bullets, stun grenades, tear gas, batons and charges on horseback." Reuters also reports that law enforcement officers "have arrested 6,877 people, mostly minors."

In both cases, curfews are used as a tool of political repression. A Kathmandu district office representative told the BBC in September 2025 that "a curfew was imposed around areas including the parliament building after protesters attempted to enter." Another official spokesman, Rajaram Basnet of the Nepal Army, said that "a small unit of soldiers had been deployed in the streets following the introduction of the curfew." In France, at least a dozen different curfews were implemented by multiple prefectures following the start of the protests, some targeting only minors.

In the US, the 2024 pro-Palestinian encampments and demonstrations on college campuses were met with brutal crackdowns from school administration. Police arrested nearly 3,000 student protestors nationwide, often using militarized tactics in the process. Universities also used disciplinary actions such as suspensions and expulsions to punish students for speaking out. At Columbia University, the response was guided not only by administrators, but also a group chat full of billionaires and business owners pressuring then-mayor Eric Adams to shut down the protests. International students, including Mohsen Mahdawi, Rümeysa Öztürk, and Mahmoud Khalil, were targeted for arrests by Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE). The administrative and governmental responses to the solidarity protests have caused a chilling effect on campus free speech.

On Social Media

Social media bans play a key role in many instances of youth political repression. One of the catalysts for the Nepalese Gen Z Revolution was the government's ban of 26 unregistered social media sites, including Facebook, Instagram, Twitter, and YouTube. Young Nepalese activists heavily used digital platforms such as Discord in their organizing; the banning of "these tools of communication [ignited] rather than extinguish[ed] the desire to communicate."

“Social media was our space to study, earn, and speak up. Now the government wants to crush our voice,” activist Miraj Dhungana explained to Fiscal Nepal. “They talk of democracy, but take away our ability to speak, earn, and connect. We are not slaves to political parties.”

The protracted effort to ban TikTok in the US tells a similar story. At first, the political rhetoric around the TikTok ban centered on its potential risk to national security at the hands of its Chinese parent company, ByteDance. However, the congresspeople who first introduced the bill, Mark Warner (D-VA) and Mike Gallagher (R-WI, former), admitted at the 2025 Munich Security Conference that the bill had been "dead until October 7th." It was the ensuing pro-Palestinian sentiment on the platform that prompted the passage of the ban. In 2024, Senator Mitt Romney also linked his support of the ban to pro-Palestinian content: "the postings on TikTok and the number of mentions of Palestinians, relative to other social media sites — it's overwhelmingly so among TikTok broadcasts." Journalist Ken Klippenstein uncovered a State Department memo which stated the Israeli government's concerns that "[y]oung people have turned against Israel in large part because the Tik-Tok algorithm favors pro-Palestinian content."

A national ban on one of the biggest social media sites in the world on account of political speech seems like it should be considered to infringe the free speech protections of the First Amendment. Unfortunately, that's not necessarily the case. Although the corporatization of the internet has consolidated much of online discussion into the hands of a few business owners, First Amendment law has yet to catch up, as law professor Genevieve Lakier explains for the Law and Political Economy (LPE) project:

Modern First Amendment law fails, in other words, to recognize one of the core precepts of law and political economy: that rights cannot be disaggregated from the material and economic relationships that make their exercise possible. This explains why courts typically do not view contractual or property-based restrictions on expressive freedom (non-disclosure agreements, for example) as actions that trigger First Amendment scrutiny, even when they are issued by government actors. It explains why ownership restrictions—even those that profoundly alter the operation of the public sphere—are not typically understood to implicate the First Amendment. And it explains why the justices were so unsure that the TikTok ban has anything to do with freedom of speech. After all, the law doesn’t directly stop anyone from speaking or listening. It just deprives them of the infrastructure that makes it possible for them to do so, at least in the particular form that the platform enabled. This is not the kind of law that courts easily recognize as a speech regulation.

However, as I've explained before, with the decline of access to physical public spaces, many young people rely on these digital platforms in order to socialize, educate themselves, and organize politically. The Electronic Frontier Foundation also recently expounded on the impacts of these restrictions on youth activism. The fact that the regulation of these platforms is not considered a first amendment issue means that young US-Americans do not have equal access to their ostensible right to free speech.

On one side, adults use social media restrictions to curtail the participation of young people in public life. On the other, they use invasive surveillance technologies to monitor young people's behavior online. A 2016 article in the journal Social Media + Society identified four US companies that contracted with school districts to monitor the social media profiles of students "during and after school." Sites like Canary Mission compile personal information about activists and their social media activity, including for university students. In 2019 and 2020, the Youth Justice Board of the Center for Justice Innovation investigated "how city systems, particularly police and schools, use social media to surveil, criminalize, and punish young people." In their final report, All Eyes on Us, they presented their findings:

[W]hat adults do with youth’s social media is largely unregulated. Youth are misinformed about how their social media is being monitored and what is being done with their information, thus making them vulnerable to unfair consequences. There is no publicly accessible data on how many teens are negatively impacted by their social media activity and there is no process or opportunity for youth to appeal decisions made.

At School

Young people face yet more restrictions on their speech at school. In the US, Tinker v. Des Moines Independent School District (1969) is considered a landmark decision regarding student First Amendment rights, and it allows for student speech and expression as long as it does not cause "substantial disruption" of school operations.

In practice, however, students are far more restricted in their speech than the Tinker test implies. In Bethel School District v. Fraser (1986), Chief Justice Warren Burger wrote:

The First Amendment guarantees wide freedom in matters of adult public discourse. A sharply divided Court upheld the right to express an antidraft viewpoint in a public place, albeit in terms highly offensive to most citizens. See Cohen v. California, 403 U. S. 15 (1971). It does not follow, however, that, simply because the use of an offensive form of expression may not be prohibited to adults making what the speaker considers a political point, the same latitude must be permitted to children in a public school. In New Jersey v. T.L.O., 469 U. S. 325, 469 U. S. 340-342 (1985), we reaffirmed that the constitutional rights of students in public school are not automatically coextensive with the rights of adults in other settings.

In short, students cannot expect the same rights as adults.

Other Supreme Court cases introducing further restrictions include Morse v. Frederick (2007) as well as Hazelwood School District v. Kuhlmeier (1988). As exemplified in Kuhlmeier, student journalists face particular pushback when their reporting challenges the viewpoints and sensibilities of adults. In this case, student journalists filed suit against their principal for withholding the publication of two articles he found objectionable (one about teen pregnancy, the other about divorce) along with five other articles that happened to be on the same pages. Justice Byron White wrote:

The standard for determining when a school may punish student expression that happens to occur on school premises is not the standard for determining when a school may refuse to lend its name and resources to the dissemination of student expression. Tinker v. Des Moines Independent Community School Dist., 393 U. S. 503, distinguished. Educators do not offend the First Amendment by exercising editorial control over the style and content of student speech in school-sponsored expressive activities, so long as their actions are reasonably related to legitimate pedagogical concerns.

There are many other examples of student journalists being punished or repressed by administrators and members of the public alike:

The Student Press Law Center tracks many similar cases.

In the Home

Young people, especially minors, also experience political repression within the home - often in ways that are harder to identify and track. When it comes to access to political information (and the education it takes to build a personal analysis of politics), children are entirely at the mercy of the adults around them. Children are especially incentivized to adopt similar views as their parents, as their parents control access to most of their survival needs as well. A 2023 report from Pew Research Center shows that most parents pass on their political and religious affiliations to their children. The particular intrafamilial mechanisms parents use to impress their beliefs on their children, and how those tactics vary across region and time period, warrant further investigation.

Parents have also worked with school administrators, local police, and even the FBI to repress their children's political organizing. Dr. Aaron Fountain Jr. uncovered hundreds of FBI surveillance and counterintelligence records about teenage activists in the 60s and 70s; in many cases, parents actively worked as informants. From his book High School Students Unite!:

Records show that while adult activists faced severe tactics - like attempts to incite violence or create internal divisions - teenagers were primarily monitored. By 1968, however, the FBI escalated its approach, conducting counterintelligence operations to stifle youth activism in high schools. What stands out is the role school officials, parents, and fellow teenagers played in these investigations. They willingly acted as informants for the FBI, police, and military intelligence, with pupils reporting on their classmates. Parents often reached out to the FBI to report on their own children's political activities.

On a social level, youth involvement in politics is often trivialized by adults (both in the home and in larger society). Political spaces rarely take particular care in accommodating the needs of young people. These attitudes create a self-fulfilling prophecy: adults think youth politics aren't "real" politics, so they devalue their contributions and create obstacles to their involvement, which further prevent young people from participating.

Conclusion

Between parents, administrators, and governments, young people face a myriad of restrictions on their political speech. Their infrastructural dependence on corporate-owned social media platforms and school-owned newspapers for political education and organizing makes it very difficult to form spaces where their speech is not constantly under threat of adult intervention. While the emergence of the internet makes it technically cheaper and more possible to disseminate information, the money and education it takes to construct alternatives remain out of reach for most minors. In the meantime, emerging technologies have provided adults many new avenues through which to monitor and suppress their speech.

(Bleak! But recognizing the extent of the problem is the first step to formulating a solution.)